Honestly, I do not know the answer to why not the "thou".
I am exploring the question "why the thou?" because, time and again, encouragement is given to delve into the meaning of what is done and said during ritual - otherwise, ritual descends to being little more than imitative mummery.
Sure, I have posted the Avatar scenario elsewhere, however, that scenario is a very hypothetical approach at the moment - and, as such, only would offer a new take on it. Putting that admittedly Chaotic experiement aside here, to return to the questions for these famous rituals:
Is the Thou the Divine Genius, the Holy Guardian Angel, etc...? Or is it indeed meant to be a recursive, self-referential, statement ritually directed?
In the case of the latter, I still wonder here why such a stance and address is taken.
Sure, there are many ways to approach explaining this issue. My questions explore what the understanding of the term (and the reasons for adopting the point of view for making the address) based upon considering two of them. So, your answer neither seems rambling, nor sophistraic, to me.
The parameters of the convo are being set here by the answers so far given. Hopefully, more people who perform this ritual and who have gained insight from it regarding the identity of the Thou will come forward and share their understanding regarding the meaning of it. If they offer different answers than those already given, I will ask questions regarding those unique answers to explore the possibilities for understanding they provide. And thus, the parameters will expand again.
Perhaps I am overcomplicating this. Yet, in light of the injunction to explore the meanings of words and gestures, the question seems simple to me - even if the various answers might lead to more involved questions for careful consideration.
|