QUOTE(palindroem @ Sep 27 2007, 02:40 PM)
There is, actually, some debate as to the efficacy of sigils outside of its use by its creator.
Ah -- but forgotten in this discussion is my motto... "Everything is real." If we are to assume that all paths are legit, and I'd argue so (I've used nearly all in the last three decades with good results from all), then so is this system. I've call myself a chaotic only because I don't believe in Dogma and believe that the heart of all magick is creativity. Chaote's practice creativity above all.
But let's put this in perspective. If we accept, the quite correct statement by Palindroem, does that mean invented sigils don't work? No, I'd argue the opposite. It takes an advanced, creative and particularly practiced and confident practitioner to make it work simply because you can't fall back on hundreds of years (or realistically, decades) of cumulative practice as you do with sigils from other great arts. At one point, all sigils were invented was the concept.
Of course, I went away for awhile (busy, sorry!) then came back, but some of you may remember I'm a heavy practitioner in Tibetan mysteries from where nearly all of Chaos methods are "borrowed." The concept of servitors, for example, is based on Tibetan Tulpas, which were merely a "lesson" from a teacher to a student that although you can create a physical entity, in the end it's actually an illusion. It's a high concept. Everything is real, and nothing is real. The concept of MIND. This is why Tibetans absorb many systems (Western, Eastern, Daoist, Buddhist, Bonn, many others) into their dynamic system. Why? Because they know EVERYTHING works, regardless of belief system. And NOTHING works, because in the end it's a manifestation of MIND. But it does impact the physical world, because in Buddhist thinking the WORLD of the physical IS MIND. Huh. It gets deeper, but then you start to sound like Kwai Chang Kane on Kung Fu.
Bottom line is that Chaos is only for advance practitioners really who have traveled many paths and know their skills. Doubt will not creep in. Creativity is magick. Everything is Real. Chaos is the ultimate freedom from Dogma and the ultimate expression of creativity. Magick is creativity. Creative Will. Will can be expressed dogmatically through systems of magic, or created. It's irrelevant to an advanced user. This is why they're called "empty hands." No tools required. Just MIND.
So, it works. Does it work all the time? No way. Because you have to have supreme confidence in your abilities. Twenty years of practicing many paths is best. It works for me. But I'll bet it doesn't work fro 99% of practitioners, who probably dabble, try it, then abandon. There are no guarantees in magick, ever. It's the skill of the practitioner that matters.
The concept by the way is really the Jungian linking to the archetypal SUPER conciousness. Yes, you plant the seed in the SUB conscious. You create a sigil simply because the subconscious works in IMAGES. A Chaotic doesn't hesitate however to borrow from other sources, so a Kabalistic symbol, a Tarot card, an ancient sigil... they're all just as good. I'm lazy, that's what I tend to do. There's the added benefit of hundreds of years of use. But it's still MIND connecting to SUB mind connecting to SUPER MIND in images. Images are the ultimate language of magick, although sound is a close second. Visualization, creativity, images, sound... all the tools anyone really needs. Self reliance is good too.
However, Chaos never ever works if there's a calculating mind involved. As soon as you analyze why something should/shouldn't work, the entire intention becomes conscious. Conscious intention is the weakest method of communicating with the super conscious (which is still us, but the US that is connected to the super mind of the Universal Mind). Too much analysis means defeat in Chaos. The best approach for a calculating mind is formalized systems, in some ways more powerful simply because they have the added value of years of imprinting. Still, it's not the creative expression of Chaos, nor as versatile.
Chaos is really a dead-on parallel to Tibetan mysteries (not Tibetan Buddhism, I'm thinking advanced Tantric and higher level work).