QUOTE(Darkmage @ Feb 9 2011, 04:37 PM)
There are things in the 'real' material world that science cannot measure--emotion comes to mind here. Does that mean emotions and feelings aren't real? What about the effects of experience? Does that mean they're not real, either?
No; I don't think I implied that, either. Instead, what I would say is that these things will eventually be measurable. In fact, emotion already is, to some extent; you can monitor brain activity.
QUOTE(Vagrant Dreamer @ Feb 9 2011, 04:51 PM)
Assuming that the 'material' world encompasses the subtle worlds that magic proposes to deal with is a major assumption. It might be true, of course, and hopefully time will tell on that. But it may also be that magic acts through a purely spiritual medium which is connected to the material world by consciousness alone - that there is no 'gradient' from material to spiritual but that there is a literal gulf between them. I suppose that without a sure knowledge either way, at this point it's a matter of placing bets, and that amounts to individual paradigms of magical cosmology.
That's true; I just think the evidence lies more heavily on one side than the other.