To respond to the second point, I think that to change the Formulae is to change the result. (This is in disagreance with most Chaos Magic(k) which offer you the choice of adapting the ritual to the point where you might as well say, 'What the hell?') These exercises were to be performed whilst the practitioner rose through their various grades on their path. There is a purpose to the description used when describing the Macrocosmic essence. It will be difficult at first but you shall prevail with practice and discipline. Of course continue with the exercise, failing that point or not, you will still gain
some of the results desired.
The first part of your question, regarding the 'sign of silence' is representative of the 'god(form) Harpocrates. By giving the sign you are using an archetypal stance that will 'still' the quadrant of the banishing. Within the Ceremonial Path of Hermetic Tradition this is the beginning use of godforms. Much meditation upon each of the Signs will bring illumination and even inspiration. These Signs represent a form of Mystery Play and form an integral part of the rite. They can also represent the forces behind certain Formulae that one will use farther along the path. Learn them all. Learn what they represent/mean. As the Enterer 'opens' the way, in this case, the 'Silence' stills the astral (within the quadrant). I hope this hasn't ended sounding more mysterious or staged. Today we have the research available that was hidden from the non-initiated when I was young.
Now it IS true that one needs to follow ones own energy and path and that we shouldn't rely on others 'spells' but to create our own BUT...these ritual were designed to work for whole groups dedicated toward the Great Work and, if followed, will provide necessary benefits. There is a
reason one should try to imagine being macrocosmic. The QC gives you a sense of balance and attunement with your universe. Practice well, practice often! Good Luck! (IMG:
style_emoticons/default/laugh.gif)